The Impact of Divorce on Investment Accounts

Divorce can have a profound impact on financial stability, especially when it comes to investment accounts. Taking proactive steps to protect these assets is crucial to mitigate potential losses. This post explores effective strategies for protecting individual investment accounts and navigating the complications that may arise during divorce proceedings.

Protecting Investment Accounts

1. Premarital Agreement

​The most effective way to protect individual investment accounts is through a premarital agreement, also known as a prenuptial agreement. This legal document outlines the ownership and distribution of assets in the event of a divorce, distinguishing between separate property (assets owned before marriage) and community property (assets acquired during the marriage). Assets identified as separate property in the agreement, including investment accounts, are not subject to division during divorce proceedings.

​Benefits of a premarital agreement include:

• ​Clarity: The agreement clearly defines separate assets, reducing ambiguity during divorce proceedings.
• Protection: This document ensures pre-marriage investment accounts remain under the original owner's control.
• Legal Standing: Courts generally uphold premarital agreements that are fair and properly executed.

2. Meticulous Documentation

​If a premarital agreement is not in place, maintaining meticulous documentation of all investment account activities becomes crucial. This includes retaining records from one month before marriage through the entire duration of the marriage. Since banks typically keep records for 5-7 years, individuals are responsible for preserving these documents beyond that period.

​Essential documents to retain:

• Account Statements: Monthly and annual statements showing balances and transactions.
• Purchase Records: Receipts or confirmations of asset purchases before marriage.
• Account Activity Logs: Detailed logs of deposits, withdrawals, and transfers.

Assets That Remain Separate Property

Under the following circumstances, the assets from investment accounts will remain separate property during a divorce, provided that there is a prenuptial agreement in place or documentation proving separateness:
​

• Increase in Asset Value: Stocks and other assets that appreciate in value can maintain their separate property status if their original ownership status is clearly established and documented. Keeping records of the asset's value at the time of marriage and any subsequent changes supports this.
• ​Asset Replacement and Mutations: When premarital assets are sold and the proceeds are reinvested in new assets, their separate property status can be maintained by documenting the direct linkage between the sale and purchase transactions.

Challenges in Protecting Investment Accounts

A primary challenge arises when investment assets become commingled with marital property. Commingling occurs when separate assets are mixed with marital assets acquired during the marriage, complicating the distinction between separate and community property.

Common causes of commingling include:

• Joint Accounts: Transferring pre-marriage investments into joint accounts.
• ​​Contributions: Using marital funds to enhance pre-marriage investment accounts.
• Reinvestment: Placing dividends or interest earned from separate property into marital accounts.

Commingling can obscure the original separate property status of assets, potentially subjecting them to division as community property during divorce proceedings.

Proving Separate Property

During divorce proceedings, the burden of proof falls on the individual claiming an asset as separate property. To successfully prove that an investment account is separate property, one must provide clear and convincing evidence. This involves:

• Providing Documentation: Presenting the meticulous documentation that clearly shows the asset was acquired before marriage and has remained separate.
• ​Tracing Funds: Demonstrating a continuous and separate path of the funds from acquisition to the present, without commingling.
• Expert Testimony: In some cases, hiring a financial expert to conduct separate property tracing and testify about the nature and history of the assets becomes necessary.

Given the high burden of proof and potential costs associated with expert testimony and legal representation, proactively protecting investment accounts from the outset can significantly reduce these expenses and improve the process of establishing their separateness.

Securing Your Financial Future

In conclusion, protecting investment accounts during divorce requires proactive measures such as establishing a premarital agreement and maintaining thorough documentation. Avoiding the commingling of assets is crucial to ensure they remain separate property. In the event of a divorce, being able to prove the separate nature of these assets is essential to protect them from division.
​
Whether you're planning for marriage and considering a premarital agreement or navigating the complexities of a divorce, seeking guidance from an experienced attorney is crucial. An attorney seasoned in family law and divorce will help you understand your rights, protect your assets, and ensure legal compliance throughout the process.