Understanding the Process of Discovery in a Civil Lawsuit in Texas

In Texas civil litigation, the discovery process is a pivotal step for gathering evidence, clarifying facts, and ensuring a fair resolution to legal disputes. Precision and diligence are crucial for attorneys and clients navigating this phase to build a strong case. This post sheds light on the discovery process's importance and key components in a Texas civil lawsuit.

The Purpose of Discovery

Discovery is a pre-trial phase during which parties involved in a civil lawsuit exchange information and evidence relevant to the case. Its primary goals are to avoid surprises at trial, encourage settlement negotiations, and promote the efficient and fair resolution of disputes. Texas law provides various mechanisms for discovery, each serving a specific purpose in the legal proceedings.

Levels of Discovery in Texas

Outlined in the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, the Discovery Control Plan categorizes all civil lawsuits into three levels, each governing the scope and limitations of the discovery process.
​

• Level 1 (Rule 190.2): Applies to suits governed by the expedited actions process in Rule 169 and divorces where the marital estate's value is less than $50,000, excluding cases involving children. Discovery begins upon filing and persists for 180 days after the first discovery request. Limits include six-hour oral depositions (extendable to ten). Interrogatories, requests for production, and requests for admissions are capped at 15 each.
• Level 2 (Rule 190.3): Encompasses all suits not governed by Level 1 or Level 3. Discovery starts at filing and persists until 30 days before the trial date in family law cases or, in other cases, until the earlier of 30 days before the trial date, nine months after the first oral deposition, or the due date of the first response to written discovery. Oral depositions are capped at 50 hours and there is a maximum of 25 interrogatories. 
• Level 3 (Rule 190.4): Ordered by the court based on specific circumstances. Allows tailored discovery plans, emphasizing a prompt court response. It may modify existing limitations and must include trial or conference dates, a defined discovery period, limits on discovery, and deadlines for crucial actions.

Key Components of Discovery

• Initial Disclosures: Parties must provide initial disclosures at the lawsuit's outset, including information about potential witnesses, relevant documents, and applicable insurance agreements. Disclosures must be provided within 30 days after filing the first answer or general appearance, or within 30 days after being served or joined, unless a different timeframe is established by a mutual agreement or a court order. As of September 1st, 2023, the Texas Legislature no longer requires initial disclosures for all family law cases.
• Written Discovery: Written discovery tools, such as interrogatories, requests for production, and requests for admissions are crucial for gathering information. Request limitations vary by discovery level.
  
• ​Oral Depositions: Oral depositions involve questioning witnesses under oath, providing an opportunity for parties to assess credibility and gather additional details beyond written responses. Texas imposes specific time constraints on the duration of oral depositions at each discovery level to ensure a focused examination.
• Expert Witnesses: Identifying and designating expert witnesses is a crucial component of the discovery process, as these professionals significantly enhance the court's understanding of complex issues. Parties must adhere to the rules governing their selection.
• ​Mediation: While not a direct part of the discovery process, most Texas courts require parties to participate in formal mediation to explore settlement options before proceeding to trial. If an agreement is reached, it is filed with the court. However, if the parties cannot reach an agreement, the case proceeds to trial.

Partner With a Skilled Attorney for Civil Litigation

Navigating civil litigation in Texas demands a strategic approach, particularly during the crucial phase of discovery. Having a seasoned attorney by your side is not just a strategic move; it's a necessity. Partnering with a skilled attorney who understands the nuances of the Texas legal system can significantly impact your case. Your attorney becomes your advocate, uncovering crucial evidence during discovery, presenting your case effectively, and skillfully negotiating on your behalf. Should mediation fail to yield an agreement, your attorney will become your advocate in the courtroom. As you face the challenges of civil litigation in Texas, a trusted legal ally can be the key to achieving a favorable resolution and safeguarding your interests.